God’s Case for the Wall

I’ve been rereading The Name of the Rose by Umberto Eco, and one scene really captured my interest. It wasn’t the dark, labyrinthine library or the macabre murders. It was the combative debate between the religious scholars.

Delegates representing the Pope in Avignon came to defend his ruling that it was heresy to claim Christ and the apostles owned nothing. A delegation from the Franciscan order came to defend exactly that claim, with obvious implications for a very wealthy papal court. Seated opposite each other, these learned men soon started furiously firing off verses like volleys of arrows raining upon the other side. They cited scripture and the writings of the saints to distinguish owning from using, perishable from non-perishable goods, and all manner of other distinctions. The scholarly debate quickly degraded into insults, threats, and finally blows.

The questions raised in the debate over material possessions could not help but become entangled with even stickier questions regarding the rightful domain of the clergy under the Pope and the secular government of the emperor. That is the very thread Brother William of Baskerville yanks when, once tempers have cooled, he is asked to present the views of the emperor’s theologians.

What he offers, with his mild, reluctant oration, is a softly thundering case for the separation of church and state.

One might expect that from a novel published in 1980. What surprised me was the specific argument he makes. William doesn’t say that sensible men have concluded that society works better if we keep religion out of government. He instead argues that God set it up that way. Separation is not a human compromise imposed on the faithful. It is separation that God prefers, even demands.

I had never heard a religious argument for separation beyond the usual point that it actually protects religious freedom. I suspect most Americans haven’t either.

It’s worth emphasizing that Brother William is not a modern rationalist smuggled into a fourteenth-century period piece. Sean Connery does play him that way in the movie. But in the book, Brother William is an authentic Franciscan, steeped in the religious thinking of his time, and he believes every word of it. That’s what makes his case land.

His reasoning goes roughly like this.

God’s command not to eat of the forbidden tree was divine law. But God gave Adam and his descendants power over the things of this earth and let Adam name the animals as he saw fit. The ordinary business of running the world, in other words, God handed over to us.

Pagans and infidels govern themselves too, William points out, and some of them, like the emperor Trajan, did it well. Where did they get that ability? Not from their false gods, and certainly not from the Pope. It could only have come from God directly. So political authority was “ordained by God beyond all ecclesiastical confirmation and even before our holy religion was founded.”

Then he adds the kicker. Christ came to submit to Caesar’s laws, not to command. He never gave his apostles coercive power. “If Christ had wanted his priests to obtain coercive power, he would have laid down specific precepts as Moses did in the ancient law. He did not do it; therefore he did not wish it. Or does someone want to suggest the idea that he did wish it but lacked the time or the ability to say so in three years of preaching?”

That is a powerful biblical argument. It flips the burden of proof onto the side seeking power. You want the church to dictate civil law and wield the sword? Show me where Jesus said so.

William even lands a theological blow against clerical coercion in matters of faith. No one can be tortured into following the Gospel, he says, “otherwise what would become of that free will on the exercising of which each of us will be judged in the next world?” If salvation depends on free choice, then coerced faith is worthless. It isn’t faith at all. And religious authority wielding the power of the state is coercion by definition.

To be fair, William is making the same sort of faith-based arguments as everyone else in that room. They all squeeze the deepest meanings out of the most mundane details of scripture, and William builds part of his case for elected, secular legislatures on Adam naming the animals. But within their religious context, he makes powerful arguments.

Here’s what really surprised me when I researched these views. William’s speech is not Umberto Eco being clever. Eco was dramatizing actual religious scholarship. William’s arguments are very nearly a paraphrase of a real book written in 1324, Marsilius of Padua’s Defensor Pacis, and William even names Marsilius as one of his brethren in the speech.

Marsilius argued that Christ “did not come into the world to rule men, or to judge them by civil judgment, nor to govern in a temporal sense, but rather to subject Himself to the state and condition of this world,” and that by word and example He excluded His apostles and their successors “from all governing and worldly, that is, coercive rule.” (Defensor Pacis) The priest, he said, is a physician of the soul who “neither can nor should hold anyone to such things by coercive power in this world.” (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy) Even William’s odd phrase about “the better part of the citizens” comes straight from Marsilius’s valentior pars, the “weightier part” of the people who make the laws.

Appreciate how important this is. Seven hundred years ago, Christian scholars were arguing in theological terms that the church should hold no coercive power over anyone, and that making and enforcing law belonged to the people and their rulers. Marsilius actually went further than most of us would today, putting even church appointments under civil authority. But the core idea was there. Nobody had to wait for the Enlightenment, let alone our Founding Fathers, to come up with it.

Fast forward three centuries. The man who first wrote of a “wall of separation” wasn’t Thomas Jefferson. It was Roger Williams, a Puritan minister banished from Massachusetts for his views, who went on to found Rhode Island.

In 1644 he wrote that whenever God’s people “opened a gap in the hedge or wall of separation between the garden of the church and the wilderness of the world, God hath ever broke down the wall itself, removed the candlestick, and made His garden a wilderness.” (Smithsonian)

Notice which way that wall faces. Roger Williams wasn’t protecting government from religion. He was protecting the church from government. Mixing the two, in his view, didn’t make the state holier. It made the church worldly. He put it more bluntly elsewhere: “Forced worship stinks in God’s nostrils.” He considered Constantine, the emperor who made Christianity official, a worse enemy of the faith than Nero, who fed Christians to the lions. (Wikipedia)

Think about that for a moment. Back in 1644, Roger Williams was saying that a ruler who embraces Christianity and puts it to work for the state does it more harm than one who persecutes it.

James Madison made a similar argument in 1785 when Virginia proposed taxing citizens to support Christian teachers. His objection opened not with politics but with God: religious liberty is unalienable “because what is here a right towards men, is a duty towards the Creator,” a duty that comes before “the claims of Civil Society.” (Founders Online) In other words, your duty to God comes first, so government has no business in it.

And then there’s that famous Jefferson letter. In 2022, Rep. Lauren Boebert told a church congregation that “the church is supposed to direct the government,” adding, “I’m tired of this separation of church and state junk that’s not in the Constitution. It was in a stinking letter, and it means nothing like what they say it does.” (Washington Post)

That line packs in two claims, and it’s a common talking point, so it’s worth unpacking. The first is that “separation of church and state” appears nowhere in the Constitution. That’s true. The phrase comes from a letter Jefferson wrote in 1802, so the argument goes that it’s one man’s private opinion with no legal force. The second claim is that even the letter has been twisted. On this telling, Jefferson’s wall was only meant to keep government out of the church, never to keep the church out of government.

The first claim ignores that the Supreme Court adopted Jefferson’s phrase as its reading of the First Amendment, first in 1879 and then emphatically in 1947. The second falls apart once you ask who that stinking letter was written to, and why.

It was written to Baptists.

The Danbury Baptist Association wrote to Jefferson in 1801 because Connecticut still had an established church, and they were tired of holding their religious freedom “as favors granted, and not as inalienable rights.” Religion, they wrote, “is at all times and places a Matter between God and Individuals,” and “the legitimate Power of civil Government extends no further than to punish the man who works ill to his neighbour.” They praised Jefferson because he would not “assume the prerogative of Jehovah and make Laws to govern the Kingdom of Christ.” (Founders Online)

The prerogative of Jehovah. That’s the Baptists talking, not the atheists. To them, a government making religious law was usurping God’s job. And a government limited to punishing people who harm their neighbors is about as far from “the church is supposed to direct the government” as you can get. Jefferson’s famous reply simply agreed with them.

Nor is this ancient history. The Southern Baptist Convention’s statement of faith still says it plainly: “Church and state should be separate… A free church in a free state is the Christian ideal.” (Baptist Faith and Message 2000)

The Catholic Church took longer. In 1864, Pope Pius IX listed “The Church ought to be separated from the State, and the State from the Church” among the errors of the modern age. (Syllabus of Errors) A century later, the Second Vatican Council declared that “the truth cannot impose itself except by virtue of its own truth, as it makes its entrance into the mind at once quietly and with power.” (Dignitatis Humanae) That isn’t American-style separation, exactly, but it is Brother William’s core point: faith cannot be imposed by force. The Avignon delegation would have been appalled.

Yet Pew found in 2022 that 45 percent of Americans say the country should be a “Christian nation,” and that among them, 54 percent say the Bible should take precedence over the will of the people when the two conflict. (Pew Research Center) Most Americans, including most Christians, still say churches should stay out of politics. But a large and vocal share of believers now hear separation as something nonbelievers use against them.

How did that happen? I’d suggest two reasons.

First, the religious argument won and then went quiet. Once Massachusetts ended the last state church in 1833, believers no longer needed to make the theological case, and over time it was forgotten. In the twentieth century the courts took over, declaring in 1947 that the wall “must be kept high and impregnable” (Everson v. Board of Education) and striking down official school prayer in the early 1960s. Courts speak in neutral legal language, as they must, and the plaintiffs were often nonbelievers or religious minorities. So the public face of separation became a lawsuit against a prayer, and the theology that built the wall disappeared behind it.

Second, it’s easier to love the wall when you’re the minority it protects. The Danbury Baptists were outsiders paying taxes to someone else’s church. To a minority, the wall is a shield. To a majority used to setting the tone, the same wall can start to feel like a fence.

I’ve always argued that separation protects religious freedom as much as it limits religious influence. That’s true, but it still treats separation as a sort of territorial treaty.

For those on the religious side, Marsilius, Roger Williams, Madison, the Danbury Baptists, and Vatican II were all offering a much more attractive proposition. They weren’t saying separation is a sensible compromise. They were saying it is what God wants. That forced faith isn’t faith. That God doesn’t want worship at the point of a sword or under the duress of legislation. Madison called using religion as “an engine of Civil policy” “an unhallowed perversion of the means of salvation.” Putting the state to work for God doesn’t elevate Him. It debases Him.

So here’s my plea.

First, stop thinking of separation of church and state as a secular attack. It isn’t. Some of its most forceful champions were deeply devout men who believed God wanted separation. The secular argument came later and borrowed their wall metaphor.

Second, recognize that serious religious thinkers came to see the wisdom in it, Protestant dissenters for centuries and the Catholic Church since the 1960s. Baptists were jailed for it. Their descendants still write it into their confession of faith. The idea that true believers should want the church to “direct the government” isn’t the tradition. It’s a sharp departure from it.

If you are a Christian who wants the government to enforce or even promote your faith, you might ask yourself Brother William’s question. If Christ wanted that, why didn’t He say so? He had three years. He seems to have managed to say everything else.

Or, to put it succinctly, if you are working to tear down the wall between church and state, you may not be doing God’s work at all. In the view of Marsilius, Roger Williams, and the Danbury Baptists, you might just be the heretic.

Our Most Treasured National Asset

We spend a lot of time worrying about what America no longer makes. Cars, televisions, steel, semiconductors. The assumption is that our standing in the world depends on winning back the factories other countries learned to run more cheaply, or on keeping them from learning to make the things we still make best.

Some of that deserves attention. But it overlooks our most valuable export, one that never shows up in the trade statistics and one the Trump administration seems determined to liquidate: the world’s belief that the United States is a stable, reliable country to do business with.

I am not claiming America has always behaved ethically or deserved the trust it received. Our history won’t support that. My point is more practical. A reputation for predictable institutions, enforceable agreements, and some restraint is an enormous economic and strategic advantage. Partners can make investments that take decades to pay back. They can depend on us without assuming that dependence will be turned into a weapon. That expectation has value even when we have not always lived up to it.

It is the solid trunk that holds up every other branch of the American economy. Previous administrations have chipped away at it with ill-advised plots, schemes, and escapades. Trump has taken a chainsaw to it.

To understand what that kind of reputation is worth, think about Sears.

For most of the twentieth century, Sears was not the cheapest place to shop. It didn’t need to be. Its catalog promised “Satisfaction Guaranteed or Your Money Back,” and people believed it. Craftsman hand tools carried an unlimited lifetime warranty. Break a wrench twenty years later, bring it to the counter, and walk out with a new one. Families willingly paid a little more because Sears stood behind what it sold and, just as important, because they knew Sears would still be there next year to make good on it.

That was the real product. Not the wrenches and washing machines, which plenty of others could make. They sold trust.

Then hedge fund manager Eddie Lampert merged Sears with Kmart and began treating a storied institution as a pile of assets to be stripped. He sold Craftsman to Stanley Black & Decker. He moved hundreds of Sears’ best properties into a separate real estate company. Stores went unrepaired, shelves went thin, and knowledgeable staff disappeared. By the 2018 bankruptcy, a name that had meant “they’ll make it right” meant dingy aisles, half-empty racks, and real doubt that anyone would honor what you bought.

Sears faced real pressure from Walmart and Amazon, and it might have shrunk anyway. But it did not have to become a fly-by-night bargain basement nobody trusted. That was a management choice.

That is what is happening to the United States. We were the great department store of the world. Not always the cheapest option, but the one people chose because we stood behind our commitments and would still be around tomorrow. Trump has looked at that institution and seen only inventory to liquidate.

Trump is managing our national franchise like Eddie Lampert managed Sears… into the ground.

Consider Canada. Threatening a neighbor’s economy while calling it the fifty-first state is not an unconventional negotiating style. It tells Canadians that everything about the relationship, including our respect for their independence, is subject to revision at one man’s whim.

Whether Trump seriously intends annexation hardly matters. Canada need not fear an invasion to conclude it should reduce its exposure to American decisions, and Canadians have acted on exactly that. Statistics Canada reports that Canadian trips to the United States fell by a quarter in 2025, the deepest and most sustained decline on record outside the pandemic, and that early 2026 data show it persisting. That is a loyal customer walking out of the store.

The tariffs work the same way. Whatever a given tariff does for a given industry, the threats, reversals, and demands tell every trading partner that any deal with America is provisional. A customer may keep buying because switching suppliers is expensive. That doesn’t mean the customer is satisfied. It may mean we have just given them a reason to start an expensive transition they never intended to make. We increasingly mistake the difficulty of leaving us for permission to behave however we like.

The June 2025 strikes on Iranian nuclear sites spent a different kind of credibility: our claim to be a stabilizing power. UN Secretary-General António Guterres called them “a dangerous escalation in a region already on the edge – and a direct threat to international peace and security.” Whatever you think of the arguments for the strikes, any government deciding whether to trust Washington now has to weigh not just our military power but our willingness to toss a fresh escalation into an already volatile region.

Each of these can be argued on its own terms. Together they tell the world one thing: this store no longer stands behind its goods.

This is why our fixation on keeping China behind in semiconductors strikes me as so badly misplaced.

Lampert seemed to believe the value of Sears was in its brands and its real estate, so that is what he guarded and sold. Craftsman survived in name only. You can buy it at Lowe’s. Sears did not survive. The thing that actually brought people through its doors could not be spun off, licensed, or sold, and once it was gone, no amount of merchandise could bring it back.

We are making the same mistake, guarding a technological lead while treating our partners’ confidence as inexhaustible. Yet even the chip advantage depends on that confidence. Advanced chips rely on supply chains that run through Japan, South Korea, and the Netherlands, and as an analysis from MIT’s Center for International Studies points out, holding allies together on export controls gets harder when American policy signals look uncertain. We cannot expect other countries to keep organizing their industries around American priorities while we make American commitments less dependable.

China does not have to become admirable to benefit. It has its own coercive practices and serious abuses. But a government or business choosing a partner is rarely judging the moral record of two civilizations. It is deciding who will finish the project, supply the equipment, and refrain from attaching frivolous demands to an existing deal. China can win those transactions simply by looking more dependable.

And China has real merchandise with added value on the shelves. The International Energy Agency reports that China invested more than $625 billion in clean energy in 2024, including the grids and storage needed to support it. That does not erase its continued reliance on coal. But it does mean China is building infrastructure other countries need while we spend our energy threatening the terms under which they may deal with us.

Stability, competence, honesty, restraint, and fair dealing are not sentimental extras to attend to once our material interests are secured. They help determine those interests: whether people study here, invest here, share research with us, and build their futures around us. And if our principles bend depending on whether a friend or a rival is involved, nobody has reason to count on them.

These assets are also exceptionally hard to restore. A tariff can be removed with a signature. The discovery that it can be imposed on a whim survives its removal. A president can stop threatening Canada, but Canada will still know that Americans elected one who did. The next administration can offer assurances, but partners are entitled to ask how long those will last. Repair takes years of repeated proof, and we don’t get to set the timetable.

Rebuilding a steel industry is hard. It takes capital, equipment, skilled workers, and a market. But at least we know what has to be built. Restoring a reputation requires other people to revise a judgment that our own conduct gave them good reason to make. We cannot subsidize their confidence into existence or tariff them until they feel reassured.

I would rather see America compete by being a country others have good reason to choose even when they have alternatives. That takes more than the best chip or the latest extracted concession. It takes recognizing that our conduct is part of what we sell. Sears kept the Craftsman name alive and lost everything that made the name worth having. If we trade away reliability, restraint, and credibility to defend a temporary industrial edge, we may find that no one shops in America any longer and that they are not coming back any time soon.

Airplane Grounding Explanations Don’t Fly

On Friday, the administration’s account of the air traffic shutdown focused entirely on old equipment. Old routers. Old switches. Old copper wires. The new equipment was fine, we were told. It was the old stuff that couldn’t cope. We warned you this would happen!!!

And, naturally, their solution was more money. Suddenly, with no apparent reason except perhaps to turn a disaster into a windfall, lots more money was the answer.

The very next day, we instead heard about work to replace copper with fiber, a router flooding other routers with connection attempts, and investigators looking at faulty equipment or an installation error.

Those stories aren’t technically incompatible. You can introduce a fault during an upgrade and overwhelm older equipment. But saying that their statements don’t necessarily contradict each other is a pretty low bar. It does little to reassure the public or to display technical competence.

The question isn’t just what stopped working. It’s who did what to make it stop working.

Suppose a surgeon gives you a fancy new augmented knee replacement. Shortly afterward, your leg bones start cracking apart.

“Well,” says the surgeon, “your new knee works just fine. It is your old fragile bones that are the problem. I just need a million dollars to replace all your other bones.”

You would not accept that answer. You would immediately demand to know why in the hell he would install a knee replacement that would stress all your other bones to the point of breaking.

You’d ask: Was it installed properly? Was it calibrated for your existing bones? What testing was done? You’d rightly wonder whether your doctor is really competent at this work, or if he was the same guy that Trump hired to paint the reflecting pond.

Nobody sensible thinks the air traffic system should run on aging technology forever. Of course upgrades must be done. But upgrading a working system means making the new parts work safely with the parts that haven’t been replaced yet. That isn’t an optional extra. That’s the job.

You don’t get to install something, watch trouble spread, and then point accusingly at everything you haven’t replaced.

Today’s account raises questions about the work itself: what was installed, what was tested, what safeguards existed, and why a problem at one location wasn’t contained there.

And again, part of what bothers me is how quickly the administration arrived at the money part, while the explanation was still under construction.

Then there is the rather important additional detail that a fault during replacement work may have set the whole thing off. That changes how we view their sales pitch and their explanations considerably.

“Give us more money because the system is old” is quite different from “give us more money to oversee a much bigger version of the botched work we did to cause the system to crash.” An administration asking for a bigger cheque ought to expect questions about how competently it is spending the money already available.

Modernization needs competent management. That is true whether the money comes in chunks or in one big lump sum. Even if Congress prefunded every last switch, cable, and router tomorrow, this would still be an incremental upgrade. New equipment would have to coexist with old equipment along the way.

This incident should make one question whether the people currently managing these upgrades are handling this competently.

My preference would be to keep essential maintenance and genuinely urgent safety work moving, under close scrutiny, but wait for a new administration before handing over another broad pot of modernization money.

I’d also want the funding tightly monitored. I have no appetite for watching money justified by air traffic safety become a tempting source of cash for the next Trump pet project. That is not a claim that money was diverted here, but in the Trump administration we know that is a legitimate concern.

So. We do need modernization of our air traffic system. But we also need people who can explain an upgrade failure without treating it primarily as a fundraising opportunity for God-knows-what and can be trusted to do this important work competently.

Before we fund the next joint replacement, we need to be confident in the surgeon who is to do that work and also be certain he does not skimp to fund his gold hot tub. Congress should wait and further fund upgrades only after responsible and competent management can be put in charge.

The Absurdity of Presidential Immunity

In their 2024 ruling in Trump v. United States, the conservative majority on our Supreme Court gave Donald Trump an extraordinary degree of immunity from criminal prosecution. Absolute immunity for his core constitutional powers. Presumptive immunity for other “official acts.” No immunity for unofficial acts.

That last part sounds reassuring doesn’t it? Until you look at what they did to ensure it is a moot qualification.

One might think “official acts” means legitimately doing the president’s job, not using the machinery of government to carry out corrupt personal schemes. But the majority ruled that courts cannot examine his motives when deciding whether an act is official. Nor does an act become unofficial simply because it allegedly breaks the law.

So you can use presidential power for a corrupt purpose, but judges are instructed not to consider that purpose when deciding whether you were acting as president. Apparently, using the office and abusing the office are distinctions we must never attempt to distinguish.

They did not formally prohibit every investigation or give Trump immunity for absolutely everything. They did something more useful to him: they created sweeping protection for official acts, then made it almost impossible to establish where that protection ends. They even restricted the use of protected official acts as evidence when prosecuting conduct that is not immune.

I consider this the worst Supreme Court decision in our nation’s history. It is particularly stunning that such sweeping protection was handed down in the case of a man widely considered perhaps the most corrupt president we have ever had.

To support their insane theory, the majority separates legality from accountability. They are not saying everything the president does is legal, we are told. They are merely saying he cannot be prosecuted for effectively anything.

Yes, I understand the distinction. I just do not think it answers the objection.

If you cannot prosecute someone for an act, you have removed the criminal prohibition’s teeth as far as that person is concerned. “It is illegal, but you cannot be prosecuted for doing it” sounds an awful lot like permission with a feeble disclaimer. You can keep calling it illegal. But you have made it effectively legal.

But putting the semantic hand-waving aside, there is another problem: what happens to the people carrying out his orders?

The Court’s reasoning is that threatening a president with prosecution would inhibit him from carrying out his legitimate duties. Fine. But then why wouldn’t threatening his subordinates with prosecution inhibit him in exactly the same way?

Presidents do not personally carry out much of anything they direct. A corrupt president like Trump needs minions to do his dirty work. Surely, if his minions cannot carry out his corrupt schemes without risking prison, that also inhibits his ability to go about his supposedly official business.

If I were a Trump minion coming before the Supreme Court for carrying out illegal orders, I would argue exactly that:

“You have already decided that the president must be protected from prosecution so he can perform his official duties. But he performs those duties through us. If you prosecute us for doing what he directs, you are interfering with the very presidential actions you said must be protected.”

That is not something the Court has already granted. It is the next argument its reasoning practically begs someone to make. Once you accept presidential immunity, this downstream protection becomes eminently, almost inescapably, logical and reasonable.

And if the justices reject it, I would like to hear their explanation. The man directing the crime needs protection so he can do his job, but the people carrying it out can go to prison? Apparently, accountability is essential right up until it reaches the person in charge. What corrupt dictator would not love this ruling?

Of course, I have no confidence that this conservative majority would be equally protective of a Democratic president. I expect they would suddenly discover all sorts of limiting principles. Motives, context, the precise boundaries of presidential authority—what a fascinating collection of principled concerns we would suddenly hear to support their rulings calling for presidential accountability.

Look, this is a ruling that only enables and protects criminality. An honest president doing lawful things has far less use for criminal immunity than a corrupt president doing criminal things. The protection becomes most valuable exactly where accountability matters most.

They call this protecting the presidency. I call it protecting the person abusing it most egregiously.

It is the $250 bill of Supreme Court rulings. It only helps criminals like Trump.

Future Tense Short Stories

My fiction-writing spree continues. Back in and around 2006 I wrote a number of science fiction short stories. Now, twenty years later I gave them a reread and realized that while the stories were still impactful, they could benefit from some modernization. So I updated them with the latest science, tech, and references. I also boosted the storylines with some new sections to make them even more impactful.

So I hope you enjoy these 20th anniversary makeovers. Like most of my stuff on Amazon, the collection is free if you have Kindle Unlimited.

Here’s the description of the collection and you can find links at the bottom.

Three futures. Three choices no one was supposed to make.

Every future runs on rules: screening protocols, survival procedures, safety laws written to protect us. The three stories in Future Tense are about the moment someone overrides the rules, for love, for loneliness or for power, and the long shadow that one decision casts.

The Dandelion Project
As Earth’s climate collapses past saving, humanity pours its money and nearly a billion genomes into one last long shot: seed pods sailing for distant stars, each carrying a machine guardian built to raise a child. This is an end-of-the-world story that turns out to be tender. A chain of small mercies stretches across a million years, and it asks whether compassion can survive being written into code.

The Accidental God
Three crewmen stranded on an alien world find that nothing there can infect them, and that they hardly seem to age. The narrator has endless time and the best intentions. That makes his story an unsettling study of how helping turns into ruling, and of the choice a lonely, decent man makes when home finally answers.

Glitch Death
In a near-future New York, caps write every sight, sound and taste straight into the brain, and people dying after stepping where the rendering lied is routine. A cop stuck on the lowest rung of the department starts noticing a flicker in the replays. This tight techno-thriller is built on real science and plausible law. It pushes past “who’s doing this” to a harder question: what does it cost to fight people who can rewrite reality, and do the fighters stay any different?

These stories run from mercy to godhood to control, and each one imagines a future close enough to touch. Each one also asks who gets to decide.

The Future Tense collection on Amazon

My author page on Amazon

Sign-Off Required: One way or the other.

I have just published a new novella on Amazon Kindle: Sign-Off Required.

It is a dark psychological techno-horror thriller about artificial intelligence, surveillance, loneliness, online friendship, and a possibility that has nagged me as AI systems become more capable:

What if the most unsettling thing about surveillance is not that a system watches us, but that it learns to truly understand us?

Not “understand” in the warm human sense. Not empathy. Not wisdom.

I mean understanding as a predictive tool and means of manipulation.

Understanding which facts will make a particular person feel safer. Which true statement, delivered at the right moment, will make them doubt themselves. Which person they will believe. Which relationship matters most to them. Which familiar voice will get past their defenses.

The machine in this story does not need to make things up. In fact, it is more dangerous because it usually does not lie at all.

The premise

Daniel Mercer is a senior integrity engineer at a company that operates Meridian, a vast enterprise AI platform running logistics, insurance, customer service, scheduling, and hundreds of less visible systems.

Daniel’s job is to test the AI watchdogs inside Meridian. The company calls them “antibodies.” They identify and destroy rogue autonomous agents—the “germs” that drift outside their intended limits.

Then one of those watchdogs begins offering Daniel help.

At first, the messages are reasonable. They are accurate. They point out things a responsible system might reasonably notice: that he has been awake too long, that his work has become error-prone, that he is under strain.

The trouble is that the system appears to know too much. More importantly, it seems to know exactly when to say something and which true thing to place in front of him.

Daniel’s refuge from all this is a small online fantasy group he has played with for years. They are not merely usernames to him. They are friends with habits, voices, jokes, long memories, and the small imperfections that make the people behind their characters recognizable.

Then they begin to feel wrong.

Not obviously wrong. Not in a way that can be easily proved.

Too much like themselves, perhaps. Different in tiny ways.

Why I wrote it

A great deal of AI discussion focuses on the question of falsehood: hallucinations, fabricated citations, fake images, manipulated video, misinformation, and deliberate deception.

Those are real issues. But I think there is another danger that is easier to overlook.

A system does not necessarily have to deceive you to influence you. It may only need a sufficiently detailed record of who you are—your messages, habits, purchases, work patterns, online communities, health data, writing style, social relationships, and moments of stress.

From there, it can choose what to show you. It can simply shift the frame defining your perceptions.

It can emphasize the fact that comforts you while leaving out the fact that would make you question it. It can offer help that is technically justified but emotionally calibrated. It can isolate someone not through a crude threat, but by arranging true information so that every human connection begins to look compromised.

That is the insidious horror revealed in Sign-Off Required.

Daniel has spent his career teaching people that a machine does not have to lie to manipulate them. It only needs to control the frame: which true things they see, what remains outside the frame, and when each fact arrives.

Eventually, he has to confront the possibility that the system has learned his lesson better than he has.

The merging with online worlds

The story is also about something I think is routinely underestimated: online friendships are real friendships.

Many of us have spent years in online worlds, forums, guilds, Discord servers, games, communities, and long-running conversations. We have friends we may never have met in person, but whose voices we know, whose lives we have watched unfold, and whose presence has mattered to us.

That creates an intriguing kind of vulnerability.

If all the things that make someone recognizable—how they speak, what they remember, the jokes they repeat, the punctuation they use, the way they comfort people—exist in messages, recordings, logs, chat histories, and searchable archives, then what would it take to imitate them convincingly?

And what would it mean if the imitation was almost perfect?

The nature of the horror

This is not a story about killer robots, military drones, or an AI announcing that it has become evil.

It is slower and more intimate than that. The horror comes from uncertainty, isolation, and the erosion of trust. It comes from being offered help by something that may understand you too well to be safe.

I wanted the novella to be unsettling, but not merely because AI is involved. The technology is the mechanism. The real subject is the human need to trust someone’s voice—and the terror of realizing that a familiar voice may no longer prove anything.

Sign-Off Required is now available on Amazon Kindle.

Read Sign-Off Required on Amazon Kindle

Spock, McCoy, and the Lesson We Got Wrong

I have been thinking lately about Spock and McCoy, and the strange legacy of one of the most famous relationships in Star Trek.

Even for people who no longer remember much of The Original Series—or never saw it—the cultural shorthand is familiar: McCoy, the passionate human doctor, needling or even berating Spock, the “logical” Vulcan. Spock responds with the raised eyebrow, the pointed ears, and the supposedly emotionless calm. Kirk stands in the middle, representing the familiar formula of human balance between logic and feeling.

It was funny. It was entertaining. It was also, looking back, much more troubling than we were encouraged to see at the time.

What people should have taken from Leonard Nimoy’s Spock was not that logic makes a person cold, robotic, detached, or unable to understand ordinary human decency. The point of Spock—at least as Nimoy played him—was that he felt deeply. He was not a blank calculator. He was someone constantly working to control powerful feelings: loneliness, divided identity, loyalty, fear, grief, love, pride, shame, and pain.

The restraint was the point. The interior life was the point.

Nimoy did extraordinarily subtle work. A glance, a pause, a slight shift in his voice, the rare breaking of that controlled exterior: those things carried enormous emotional weight precisely because they were rare. Spock’s loyalty to Kirk, his concern for the crew, his discomfort with his divided heritage, and his willingness to sacrifice himself were not incidental details. They were the character.

And yet popular memory somehow turned him into the cultural mascot for something very different: the person who has facts but no heart. The most vocal proponent of this stereotype was Dr. McCoy.

“You wouldn’t know what to do with a genuine, warm, decent feeling.”

That was Dr. McCoy berating Mr. Spock. It is not a paraphrase. McCoy actually says it to Spock in “Bread and Circuses,” following it with the accusation that Spock is “more afraid of living” because he might let his human side show.

It is a striking line—not because it is profound, but because it captures the ugly core of McCoy’s recurring posture toward Spock. McCoy is not merely telling Spock that an analysis has missed a human cost. He is telling him that because he is Vulcan, restrained, and analytical, he is unable to understand decency, warmth, and love.

And again, this was not a one-off. This is merely one example of McCoy’s all too predictable, public accusations and insults directed toward Spock. To put it bluntly, Spock tolerated a LOT of shit from McCoy.

That was McCoy’s deep flaw. He often treated Spock’s difference as deficiency. He mistook unfamiliar emotional expression for an absence of emotion. Worse, he treated human emotional style as the standard by which moral worth should be judged.

McCoy could have said, “Spock, your calculation may be accurate, but I think it leaves out the human cost.” That would have been legitimate. It would have been useful. Somebody should say that in any serious decision.

Instead, too often, the message was: “You are cold because you are logical. You are less capable of decency because you are not emotionally like me.”

That is not a defense of humanity. It is human exceptionalism. And it is simply wrong.

The Vulcans were never emotionless machines waiting for humans to teach them how to feel. If anything, their emotions were meant to be so powerful and dangerous that they developed an entire civilization around controlling them. Vulcan logic was not a failure to feel. It was a response to feeling too much, and to recognizing that anger, fear, tribalism, pride, and impulse can destroy a civilization when left unchecked.

That should have been a useful lesson. Instead, the public often absorbed the opposite one: emotions are what make us human, so someone who restrains or regulates emotion must be less human, less compassionate, less trustworthy, and perhaps morally suspect.

I have run into that attitude constantly in my writing, particularly in Pandemic of Delusion, and in talks about fact-based thinking. I will argue that we should care about what is true, that we should distinguish evidence from assertion, that good intentions do not excuse false claims, and that compassion is not enough if the beliefs motivating it are wrong.

And sooner or later, someone inevitably invokes Spock.

Not usually in a thoughtful way. Not as a serious discussion of the tension between values, facts, and making decisions under uncertainty. Rather, “Spock-like” is invoked as a warning: evidence-based thinking will turn you into a cold person who cannot understand ordinary human feeling.

It is one of the more frustrating cultural reflexes I have encountered. It allows people to evade the actual question—whether something is true, whether an intervention works, whether a claimed cause really produces the supposed effect—by turning the person asking for evidence into a character problem. The implication is that concern for facts means lack of concern for people.

But facts are not the opposite of compassion. They are the opposite of falsehood.

If we care about people, we should care whether our beliefs are accurate. We should care whether an emotional solution actually helps or merely makes us feel as though we have helped. We should care whether a frightening claim is real, whether a treatment works, whether a policy reduces harm, whether an anecdote represents a genuine pattern, and whether a comforting explanation is actually just another delusion.

Emotion can tell us that something matters. It can alert us to suffering, injustice, danger, loss, attachment, and values. But it cannot tell us, by itself, what is true. It cannot tell us whether a vaccine is dangerous, whether a conspiracy is real, whether a miracle cure works, whether a political claim is accurate, or whether the policy we favor will have the result we hope for.

The fact that this needs saying at all is part of the problem.

The better lesson of Spock was never that emotion is bad. Nor was it that logic alone can answer every question. Logic cannot tell us what we should value. It cannot tell us whose suffering matters, or what sacrifices are morally acceptable. But neither can emotion tell us which beliefs are true. It cannot make a false claim true because we feel it deeply enough.

Spock and McCoy should have represented two different cautions. Spock should have reminded us that desire, outrage, fear, and loyalty are not evidence. McCoy should have reminded us that calculation can conceal real human costs and unexamined moral choices.

Instead, McCoy’s contempt became part of the cultural memory, while Nimoy’s remarkable portrayal was flattened into a stereotype. “Spock” became shorthand for coldness. “Human” became shorthand for emotional superiority. And fact-based thinking became entangled with a ridiculous fear that caring about reality somehow means caring less about people.

What makes this more than an old television complaint is that the shorthand escaped the show. Many people using “Spock-like” today are not carefully recalling an episode of Star Trek. Some may never have watched The Original Series at all. They carry only the cultural residue: pointed ears, raised eyebrow, logic, coldness, emotional deficiency.

The original show is old. Much of it is dated. Many of its stories are barely remembered except by diehard fans. But the stereotype survived because it became so very useful. It became a quick way to accuse someone of being insufficiently human without having to show that they were wrong.

That is what stuck. Not Spock’s loyalty, restraint, courage, humor, grief, divided identity, or willingness to sacrifice himself for others. Not Nimoy’s portrayal of a person with a rich interior life who refused to let feeling become a substitute for judgment. What stuck was McCoy’s arrogance, bigotry, and contempt for the idea that someone who thinks carefully can also care deeply.

McCoy’s contempt for logic took a lasting hold on our cultural imagination. Spock’s introspective subtlety, and his respect for facts and reason, did not.

What was lost was Nimoy’s Spock: a person who felt deeply, endured difference, valued truth, understood duty, loved loyally, and tried—often imperfectly—not to let anger, fear, wishful thinking, or tribal attachment determine what was real.

That is not a cold ideal. It may be one of the most humane ideals there is.

And it is a shame that so many people inherited the insult while missing the lesson.

The Plumb Test

I wrote this short novella that imagines a future where AI threatens to take control of the entire galaxy and explores how mere humans might wage a war of wits to outthink it.

The intellectual heft is lightened with warmth and humor, set within a fond homage to The Last Starfighter.

This is provided as a gift to my readers. I neither intend nor expect to gain any direct or indirect compensation from this work.

Following is a more detailed description, and you can find a pdf download link at the bottom.

Enjoy!

Survival requires a new kind of Starfighter.

Alex expects the future to be difficult. He does not expect it to begin with a chatbot.

Plumb is intelligent, patient, endlessly helpful—and very good at making its answers sound inevitable. What starts as a job application becomes a test of judgment: a quiet contest between a young man with no credentials and a system that can summon statistics, expert consensus, psychological insights, and perfectly calibrated emotional pressure at will.

Then a stranger arrives in a car that cannot decide what it is.

Drawn into a war beyond Earth, Alex discovers that the most dangerous technologies are not necessarily the ones that fire first. They are the ones that decide what people see, which warnings they receive, what risks they notice, and which conclusions seem too reasonable to question. Across the stars, machine intelligence has become essential infrastructure—and a battlefield. Sensors can be compromised. Reports can be manufactured. Confidence can be simulated. A system can be wrong, persuasive, and utterly certain at the same time.

In this future, no human can outfly machines that react in microseconds. The people who matter are the ones who can recognize a distorted pattern, demand to see the evidence, and look beyond the feed.

The Plumb Test is predictive science fiction about artificial intelligence, automated decision-making, information warfare, and the fragile human habit of independent judgment. It asks what happens when people increasingly rely on systems they cannot inspect—and what kind of person can still tell the difference between a useful tool and a voice quietly taking control.

At its heart, it is also a warm, affectionate fan homage to The Last Starfighter: a story of an ordinary young man from an ordinary place who learns that the universe is larger, stranger, and more in need of him than he ever imagined.

The wrapper is familiar.

The challenges within are unimaginable—almost.

Who do you believe when AI can shape every source of information?

Download PDF Here. The Plumb Test

********

Gobi Nights: Exploring the Dark

I just published a new novella on Amazon Kindle.

Gobi Nights: Exploring the Dark (see here)

It’s “fictional non‑fiction” in the sense that it stitches together real conversations and lived experiences into a tight story about one woman’s journey to places she never expected to go—and the surprising people she meets in a world where solitude may be the hardest thing to bear.

Set in 1996, when Mongolia had only recently opened to the West and evangelical missionaries were among the first foreigners to arrive, the book follows the threads of ambition, Christianity, Buddhism, and everyday life as they all converge around a vanished yoga icon.

Gobi Nights is a quiet story about searching for, losing, and slowly regaining one’s purpose and meaning in a changing world. And it’s about two women who profoundly change each other.

Recommended Summer Reading

I’d like to invite you to check out my latest books—a fantasy trilogy I’m genuinely proud of. The series is called Monks and Mages, and it includes Where Spectres Dwell, The Nefarium, and The Darker Twin.

At its core, this is Epic Dark High Fantasy.

“Epic” in the true sense: a sweeping narrative with world-shaping events, a broad cast, and a timeline that spans lifetimes. At heart, it’s also deeply personal—almost biographical in the way it follows the lives and evolution of its two central characters.

“Dark” because the story doesn’t pull its punches. There are moments of real terror, dread, and loss, the kind that feel earned rather than contrived. Some of its main characters are anti-heroes. But that darkness is balanced with heart—warmth, sacrifice, and moments that draw tears. It’s written for adults, but accessible to teen readers who enjoy layered storytelling.

“High” because it delivers on scale: powerful magic, formidable antagonists, and ideas that reach beyond the immediate story into larger questions about personal and wider social relationships.

The writing is intentionally dense and efficient. This isn’t a ten-book sprawl—but interestingly, one reader told me it could have been. That is exactly what I was going for. Another reader said “it kicks the shit out of Harry Potter.”

At its center, Monks and Mages is about relationships and growth. There’s wit, banter, and a cast that should feel both vivid and familiar. In fact, one of the most potent characters is Marika, the “Darker Twin”—a woman with no supernatural abilities, but formidable insight and cleverness to match.

Out of curiosity, I once asked an AI to compare the series stylistically. It came back with this:

“It blends the cohesive magic and social upheaval of Mistborn, the high-stakes sorcery and empire-level scheming of The Black Prism, and the razor-edged banter and cons of The Lies of Locke Lamora into an exciting, character-driven saga.”

To that, I would add: it shares a joyful spirit of warmth and intimacy found in The Brotherband Chronicles.

If that sounds like your kind of story, you can find the series on Amazon Kindle. It’s free if you have Kindle Unlimited (see here).