Tag Archives: Trump administration

Airplane Grounding Explanations Don’t Fly

On Friday, the administration’s account of the air traffic shutdown focused entirely on old equipment. Old routers. Old switches. Old copper wires. The new equipment was fine, we were told. It was the old stuff that couldn’t cope. We warned you this would happen!!!

And, naturally, their solution was more money. Suddenly, with no apparent reason except perhaps to turn a disaster into a windfall, lots more money was the answer.

The very next day, we instead heard about work to replace copper with fiber, a router flooding other routers with connection attempts, and investigators looking at faulty equipment or an installation error.

Those stories aren’t technically incompatible. You can introduce a fault during an upgrade and overwhelm older equipment. But saying that their statements don’t necessarily contradict each other is a pretty low bar. It does little to reassure the public or to display technical competence.

The question isn’t just what stopped working. It’s who did what to make it stop working.

Suppose a surgeon gives you a fancy new augmented knee replacement. Shortly afterward, your leg bones start cracking apart.

“Well,” says the surgeon, “your new knee works just fine. It is your old fragile bones that are the problem. I just need a million dollars to replace all your other bones.”

You would not accept that answer. You would immediately demand to know why in the hell he would install a knee replacement that would stress all your other bones to the point of breaking.

You’d ask: Was it installed properly? Was it calibrated for your existing bones? What testing was done? You’d rightly wonder whether your doctor is really competent at this work, or if he was the same guy that Trump hired to paint the reflecting pond.

Nobody sensible thinks the air traffic system should run on aging technology forever. Of course upgrades must be done. But upgrading a working system means making the new parts work safely with the parts that haven’t been replaced yet. That isn’t an optional extra. That’s the job.

You don’t get to install something, watch trouble spread, and then point accusingly at everything you haven’t replaced.

Today’s account raises questions about the work itself: what was installed, what was tested, what safeguards existed, and why a problem at one location wasn’t contained there.

And again, part of what bothers me is how quickly the administration arrived at the money part, while the explanation was still under construction.

Then there is the rather important additional detail that a fault during replacement work may have set the whole thing off. That changes how we view their sales pitch and their explanations considerably.

“Give us more money because the system is old” is quite different from “give us more money to oversee a much bigger version of the botched work we did to cause the system to crash.” An administration asking for a bigger cheque ought to expect questions about how competently it is spending the money already available.

Modernization needs competent management. That is true whether the money comes in chunks or in one big lump sum. Even if Congress prefunded every last switch, cable, and router tomorrow, this would still be an incremental upgrade. New equipment would have to coexist with old equipment along the way.

This incident should make one question whether the people currently managing these upgrades are handling this competently.

My preference would be to keep essential maintenance and genuinely urgent safety work moving, under close scrutiny, but wait for a new administration before handing over another broad pot of modernization money.

I’d also want the funding tightly monitored. I have no appetite for watching money justified by air traffic safety become a tempting source of cash for the next Trump pet project. That is not a claim that money was diverted here, but in the Trump administration we know that is a legitimate concern.

So. We do need modernization of our air traffic system. But we also need people who can explain an upgrade failure without treating it primarily as a fundraising opportunity for God-knows-what and can be trusted to do this important work competently.

Before we fund the next joint replacement, we need to be confident in the surgeon who is to do that work and also be certain he does not skimp to fund his gold hot tub. Congress should wait and further fund upgrades only after responsible and competent management can be put in charge.